Star Group Boston Consulting Group Matrix
Fully Editable
Tailor To Your Needs In Excel Or Sheets
Professional Design
Trusted, Industry-Standard Templates
Pre-Built
For Quick And Efficient Use
No Expertise Is Needed
Easy To Follow
Star Group Bundle
See the Bigger Picture
Here’s the Star Group BCG Matrix in brief: spot-on stars driving growth, a couple of cash cows funding R&D, and clear question marks that deserve a call-to-action. Want the full picture—quadrant-by-quadrant data, strategic moves and ready-to-use Word and Excel files? Purchase the complete BCG Matrix for actionable insight you can present and implement tomorrow.
Stars
Propane delivery growth lanes
Propane delivery growth lanes: 2024 Northeast exurbs show ~4% regional propane demand growth, and Star already runs core routes and 120 delivery trucks, capturing roughly 35% local share; rising oil-to-propane conversions bolster volume. Continue investing in tanks, telemetry, and 20 additional sales reps to sustain high-share, high-growth positioning and build a future cash cow.
HVAC installs + service bundles
End-to-end HVAC installs tied to multi‑year service plans scale fast and defend share: 2024 industry data shows service attachment rates rising to roughly 20–30%, with each contract typically locking in fuel delivery and recurring revenue. Capital outlay is high up front, but payback tends to be steady and sticky, often within 3–5 years. Prioritize tech hiring, ongoing training, and targeted local marketing to sustain growth.
Automatic delivery with smart routing
Usage analytics, tank monitors and optimized routing have boosted retention by ~20% and reduced drops per gallon ~12% in 2024 pilots, lifting margins while taking wallet share in core territories where Star already holds over 40% share. Hardware and IT capex depress cash flow short-term but pay back via lower churn and higher unit economics; double down while adoption is steep.
Bioheat blended offerings
Regulatory tailwinds and rising customer curiosity are moving Bioheat (commonly B5–B20 blends) from niche to norm; the Northeast — ~80% of US heating oil demand — is seeing brisk growth and tangible brand premiums. Star’s early positioning and supply partnerships give a clear edge in dense markets; continued education and supply-chain reliability will cement leadership.
- Regulatory momentum: mandates & incentives rising
- Product: B5–B20 blends gaining share
- Market focus: Northeast concentration (~80%)
- Priority: education + supply reliability
Commercial service agreements
Commercial service agreements target light-commercial clients demanding 99.9% uptime SLAs and single‑throat accountability; Star holds strong metro share and the segment is expanding with 7–10 year retrofit cycles. Contracts deliver predictable, recurring revenue (over 60% of division in 2024) but require tech capacity and parts inventory; scale PM programs and SLAs to stay ahead.
- Uptime target: 99.9%
- Retrofit cycle: 7–10 years
- Recurring revenue: >60% (2024)
- Focus: PM scale, SLAs, parts on hand
Northeast heating: propane up 4% — fleet growth, service attach lifts margins, bioheat gains
2024 propane demand +4% in Northeast; Star runs 120 trucks, ~35% local share; invest in tanks, telemetry, +20 reps. HVAC installs lift service attachment to 20–30% with 3–5 year payback. Pilots: retention +20%, drops/gallon −12%. Bioheat (B5–B20) gaining share; Northeast ≈80% of US heating oil demand.
| Metric | 2024 |
|---|---|
| Propane growth | +4% |
| Truck fleet | 120 |
| Local share | 35% |
| Service attach | 20–30% |
| Retention | +20% |
| Drops/gal | −12% |
| Northeast heating oil | ≈80% |
What is included in the product
Detailed Word Document
BCG Matrix review of Star Group products with quadrant insights—recommendations to invest, hold or divest and noted risks.
Customizable Excel Spreadsheet
One-page Star Group BCG Matrix that clarifies portfolio pain points for fast C-suite decisions and slide-ready exports.
Cash Cows
Heating oil delivery in mature zips
Heating oil delivery in mature zips behaves like an annuity: customer retention >90% and churn <5% in 2024, with volumes stable year‑over‑year variability under 3%. Minimal promo spend (below 1% of revenue) lets operators focus on margin expansion (EBITDA ~10–15%) and routing efficiency. Milk by tightening routes to 50–70 stops/day, enforcing price discipline, and keeping DSO under 20 days via strict credit controls.
Annual maintenance contracts
Annual maintenance contracts show renewal rates of about 90% in 2024, with prepaid cash flow providing steady working capital. Work is scheduled, parts are standard and technician hours are predictable, enabling tight cost control. Growth is limited but AMCs contributed roughly 30% of Star Group service revenue in 2024, delivering strong margin uplift. Maintain via light retention incentives and zero-friction, automated renewals.
Service parts and consumables
No one gets rich on nozzles and filters, but margin per service call is sweet: aftermarket service parts commonly carry gross margins of 30–50% in 2024. Volume is steady and tied to installed fleets, with attach rates often above 65% and recurring parts representing over half of parts revenue. Low marketing spend, high attach rate, lean inventory (6–12 turns/year) and consistent pricing keep cash flows predictable.
Fuel price protection programs
Fuel price protection programs lock customers into plans that stabilize demand and cut churn; customers pay for certainty while Star captures a spread and builds loyalty. Growth is limited but cash generation remains reliable; Brent averaged about 86 USD/bbl and global oil demand ~101.6 mb/d in 2024, underscoring ongoing hedging relevance. Maintain strict hedging discipline and simple plan options.
- Locked‑in plans: lower churn
- Customers pay for certainty; Star earns spread
- Reliable cash generation despite limited growth
- 2024 context: Brent ~86 USD/bbl, demand ~101.6 mb/d
- Action: strict hedging, simple offerings
Tank leasing fees
Tank leasing fees from Star Group’s installed base generate recurring revenue with minimal sales effort; retention exceeds 95% once a tank is deployed (2024 operational benchmarks), making churn immaterial and economics predictable. Margins are high—roughly 50–65% EBITDA for regulated tank-leasing lines in 2024—so the business is low-glamour but very profitable. Keep compliance strict and service turnaround 24–48 hours to avoid costly downtime.
Cash cows: heating, AMCs, parts, tanks driving steady EBITDA and cash flow
Cash cows: high-retention, low-growth assets delivering steady EBITDA and cash: heating delivery (retention >90%, churn <5%, EBITDA 10–15%, DSO <20), AMCs (renewal ~90%, 30% service rev), parts (margins 30–50%, turns 6–12), tanks (retention >95%, EBITDA 50–65%), fuel hedges stable (Brent ~86 USD/bbl 2024).
| Line | 2024 KPI | EBITDA |
|---|---|---|
| Heating delivery | Retention >90%, churn <5%, DSO <20 | 10–15% |
| AMCs | Renewal ~90%, 30% rev | High |
| Parts | Margins 30–50%, turns 6–12 | 30–50% |
| Tank leasing | Retention >95% | 50–65% |
Full Transparency, Always
Star Group BCG Matrix
The file you're previewing is the exact Star Group BCG Matrix you'll receive after purchase. No watermarks or demo content—just the fully formatted, analysis-ready report. It's crafted for strategic clarity and immediate use, editable and printable. Buy once, download instantly—no surprises, no extra steps.
Dogs
Standalone equipment retail
Standalone equipment retail burns time and margin selling boxes without install or service ties; industry e-commerce penetration reached ~21% of global retail sales in 2023 (Statista), intensifying price competition. With low share and low growth versus service-led segments, units dilute delivery economics and do not feed the delivery flywheel. Trim SKUs aggressively or exit low-margin lines to protect gross margins and logistics ROI.
Legacy kerosene micro‑routes
Legacy kerosene micro-routes are low-density dogs: tiny, scattered stops crush route efficiency and tie up trucks, with inventory carrying costs in the sector typically 20–30% p.a., compressing margins. Demand drifts down annually while price pressure erodes per-stop revenue, forcing cash into inventory and rolling costs. Consolidate or divest those pockets to free working capital and improve fleet utilization.
Print‑heavy direct mail blasts
Print‑heavy direct mail blasts
Response rates have slid to roughly 4.9% for house lists and about 1.0% for prospect lists per DMA benchmarks, while unit costs rose after USPS rate hikes in 2024. Digital targeting now outperforms with higher ROI and less waste—global digital ad spend reached roughly $600B in 2024, reflecting performance channel preference. Low growth and low ROI categorize this as a Dog; cut spend and redeploy to performance channels.
One‑off emergency repair calls
One‑off emergency repair calls
They spike at 02:00 and vanish by sunrise—about 70% of incidents occur 00:00–06:00 and average ticket $120 vs. CAC $200, yielding near‑zero lifetime value. Tech burnout (25% annual turnover) and parts chaos (stockout premium ~18%) erode margins; service holds <5% share with no viable growth path. Keep only as a funnel into contracts; otherwise pass.- Peak window: 00:00–06:00 (~70%)
- Avg ticket $120 / CAC $200
- Tech turnover 25% p.a.
- Parts stockout premium +18%
- Market share <5% — no growth
Non‑core outlier territories
Non-core outlier territories house far‑flung depots with thin density that drain dispatch efficiency and management attention; 2024 Star Group internal ops show ~8% of depots deliver only ~1.5% of volume and sit at break‑even or loss. Entrenched local competitors and fixed costs mean volume won’t justify capex; recommend sell or tuck into nearby dealers to cut operating drag.
- Depot share: ~8%
- Volume contribution: ~1.5%
- Financial status: break‑even/negative
- Action: sell or integrate with local dealers
Stop margin leaks: divest low-share depots/routes, reallocate to digital ad spend
Low‑share/low‑growth units drain margins and logistics: standalone retail, legacy micro‑routes, print blasts, one‑off repairs and distant depots show weak ROI (avg ticket $120 vs CAC $200), depot slice 8% delivers 1.5% volume; cut SKUs, divest routes/depots, shift spend to digital ($600B global ad spend 2024).
| Item | Metric |
|---|---|
| Avg ticket/CAC | $120 / $200 |
| Depot share/volume | 8% / 1.5% |
| Digital ad spend 2024 | $600B |
Question Marks
Heat pump installations
Market incentives such as the US Residential Clean Energy Tax Credit (30% through 2032) have pushed heat pump demand sharply higher in 2024, yet Star still holds a single-digit share versus specialist installers. Adoption cannibalizes some fossil-fuel revenue but creates a long runway of recurring service and maintenance fees. Decide quickly: build a dedicated crew and marketing or partner with specialists; invest to scale only if attach rates to service contracts exceed ~50%.
EV charger installs
Home energy adjacency is clear as global EV sales reached about 11 million in 2024, but brand permission for home charger installs isn’t guaranteed and requires channel trust. Growth is hot while Star’s footprint remains early; unit economics hinge on permitting speed and electrician capacity—US 2024 electrician workforce ~750,000 and local permit delays add weeks. Pilot in core metros, measure CAC and push for payback within 12–24 months.
Renewable propane blends
Renewable propane blends sit in the Question Marks quadrant: supply is scarce and pricing opaque, with renewables accounting for under 1% of global LPG supply in 2024, so adoption is uneven across regions.
Customer interest is tangible and regulatory pressure is rising—EU and UK net-zero policies in 2024 increased demand signals for low-carbon fuel solutions.
Low share today but potential to become a Star if Star Group secures upstream feedstock, signs offtakes, and pilots premium tiers with fleet customers to capture pricing uplift.
Home energy monitoring subscriptions
Whole‑home generators
Whole‑home generators are a Question Mark: outage anxiety drives purchase intent and the US residential standby market showed continued growth in 2024, yet the category is crowded with installers and Star holds a single‑digit market share. Install plus recurring maintenance can yield high lifetime revenue, but 8–12 week lead times and parts logistics (transfer switches, controllers) are current choke points. Test bundled offers with fuel plans and service contracts before scaling.
- Market 2024 growth: mid single‑digit CAGR
- Star share: single‑digit
- Lead times: 8–12 weeks
- Revenue mix: strong install + recurring service
- Priority: pilot bundles with fuel/service
2024: Heat pump demand up on 30% credit; EV installs need trusted channels
Question Marks: 2024 demand spikes (heat pumps aided by 30% US tax credit) vs Star single‑digit share; EV home installs (global EVs ~11M) need channel trust; renewable LPG <1% supply; home sensors ($50–150 HW; ARPU $5–10/mo) require churn <3–5% to be viable; whole‑home generators face 8–12 week lead times but high LTV if bundled.
| Category | 2024 Metric | Star status |
|---|---|---|
| Heat pumps | Tax credit 30%, demand ↑ | Single‑digit share |
| EV chargers | 11M EVs | Pilot metros |
| Sensors | $50–150; $5–10/mo | Trial |