The New York Times Business Model Canvas
Fully Editable
Tailor To Your Needs In Excel Or Sheets
Professional Design
Trusted, Industry-Standard Templates
Pre-Built
For Quick And Efficient Use
No Expertise Is Needed
Easy To Follow
The New York Times Bundle
Unlock the strategic blueprint behind The New York Times with a concise Business Model Canvas that maps its value propositions, revenue mix, and growth levers. This snapshot is perfect for investors, consultants, and founders seeking practical insight. Download the full, editable Canvas (Word/Excel) to explore every building block and apply it to your strategy.
Partnerships
Alliances with Apple, Google and major podcast platforms extend The New York Times reach across mobile, search and audio, supporting discovery for a publisher with over 10 million paying subscribers by mid-2024; app store relationships streamline payments and user acquisition amid 15–30% platform commission structures. Smart speaker and connected TV integrations add new touchpoints, reducing friction and broadening the audience funnel.
Advertising agencies and direct brand marketers drive premium demand across The New York Times news, podcasts, video and newsletters, leveraging the publisher’s ~9.6 million subscribers in 2024 to target high-value audiences. Joint planning and branded-content collaborations measurably boost campaign effectiveness and time-on-site. Data-sharing and measurement partnerships improve attribution, while multi-year and programmatic guaranteed deals increase revenue visibility.
Ties with AP and Reuters, each operating across 100+ countries, boost geographic coverage and speed for the New York Times, while independent journalists extend reach into niche and local markets. Flexible access to subject-matter freelancers and stringers supports breaking news and specialized beats. Contracted contributors balance quality with cost efficiency, fortifying coverage breadth without fully fixed staffing.
Printing and logistics providers
Printing and logistics providers—external presses and regional distribution networks—support NYT print production and last-mile delivery, preserving legacy readership while optimizing capex. Mid-2024 NYT reported about 9.6 million total subscribers, underscoring continued print demand in certain markets. Regional partners ensure timeliness and cost control; redundant suppliers reduce operational risk.
- External presses: scalability, lower capex
- Regional partners: timeliness, cost control
- 9.6M subscribers (mid-2024)
- Redundancy: reduces distribution outages
Technology, data, and analytics vendors
Technology, data, and analytics vendors power the New York Times paywall, CMS, cloud-hosted delivery and measurement to boost personalization and performance. Cloud services (global public cloud market 614B in 2024 per Gartner) and ad-tech/fraud-prevention partners protect yield and brand safety. Experimentation and A/B testing tools drive lifecycle optimization while vendor ecosystems accelerate innovation without rebuilding in-house.
- Cloud: public cloud market 614B (2024)
- Paywall/CMS: personalization & revenue
- Ad-tech/fraud: yield & brand safety
- Experimentation: A/B testing & lifecycle
- Vendor ecosystems: faster innovation
Alliances with Apple, Google and podcast platforms expand reach and discovery, supporting ~9.6M subscribers (mid-2024) and reducing acquisition friction amid 15–30% platform fees. Agency and brand partners drive premium ad revenue and measurement. AP/Reuters and freelancers extend global coverage. Cloud, ad-tech and printing partners (public cloud market $614B, 2024) enable scale and resilience.
| Partner | Role | Key metric |
|---|---|---|
| Apple/Google | Distribution/payments | 15–30% fees |
| Agencies/Brands | Ad demand | ~9.6M subs |
| AP/Reuters | News supply | 100+ countries |
| Cloud/Printing | Delivery/scale | $614B cloud (2024) |
What is included in the product
A comprehensive Business Model Canvas for The New York Times, organized into the 9 classic blocks and detailing customer segments (subscribers, advertisers, institutions), channels (website, apps, newsletters), value propositions (trusted journalism, premium digital products), revenue streams (subscriptions, advertising, licensing), cost structure, key partners, competitive advantages, and SWOT-linked insights—ideal for presentations and investor discussions.
Editable one-page canvas that clarifies The New York Times’ revenue streams, customer segments, and costs—saving hours of setup and enabling fast strategic comparisons, team collaboration, and board-ready summaries.
Activities
Daily newsgathering and rigorous editorial processes at The New York Times, serving over 9 million paid subscribers in 2024, ensure accuracy and depth through multi-source verification. Investigations and data journalism teams produce distinctive, enterprise reporting that drives subscriptions. Speed-to-publish balances with fact-checking to compete with real-time cycles. Strict editorial standards protect trust and brand equity.
Continuous improvements to apps, site, paywall, and search boost UX and retention, supporting The New York Times' subscriber base of about 11.1 million (Q2 2024). Personalization, recommendations, and performance tuning lift engagement and time-on-site, driving higher ARPU from cross-sell. Cross-product integration links News, Games (≈2M players/subscribers), Cooking and Wirecutter to expand revenue per user while roadmaps target sustainable subscriber growth.
Lifecycle marketing, pricing tests, and bundling drive conversions for The New York Times, supporting growth to over 10 million paying subscribers in 2024; targeted offers and A/B pricing lift sign-ups and ARPU. Onboarding flows, habit-loop product design, and automated win-back campaigns reduce churn and extend tenure. Newsletters, alerts, and push notifications create daily active use, while analytics monitor cohort health and guide LTV expansion.
Advertising sales and monetization operations
Premium direct sales, programmatic yield and branded content drive The New York Times ad mix, complementing ~9.5 million subscribers reported in 2024 to sustain diversified revenue.
Precision targeting, frequency capping and viewability metrics optimize campaign outcomes and CPMs across desktop and mobile.
Podcast and newsletter sponsorships expand formats while strict compliance and brand-safety standards preserve advertiser trust.
- premium direct
- programmatic yield
- branded content
- targeting & viewability
- podcast/newsletter ads
- compliance
Content diversification and IP development
Content diversification—podcasts, video, games, Cooking guides and reviews—expands audiences and feeds the NYT ecosystem; as of 2024 The New York Times reported about 11.1 million paid subscriptions, enabling scale for cross-format launches. Franchises and series deepen loyalty, create licensing-ready IP, and cross-promotion increases multi-product adoption. IP extensions produce incremental monetization via licensing, events and product sales.
- Podcasts: audience growth + cross-promo
- Video & games: engagement, new ARPU
- Cooking & reviews: platform stickiness
- Franchises: licensing & events
- Cross-promotion: higher multi-product adoption
Daily newsgathering, investigations and strict editing support trust and fuel subscriptions (11.1M paid, Q2 2024). Product engineering—apps, paywall, personalization—boosts engagement and ARPU; Games ~2M players and Cooking/Wirecutter cross-sell. Marketing, pricing tests and lifecycle campaigns drive conversion and reduce churn. Ad sales, programmatic, branded content and podcast/newsletter ads diversify revenue.
| Activity | Key metric (2024) |
|---|---|
| Subscriptions & reporting | 11.1M paid |
| Games | ~2M players |
| Ads & branded content | Programmatic + direct mix |
Full Document Unlocks After Purchase
Business Model Canvas
The New York Times Business Model Canvas previewed here is the actual deliverable—not a mockup or sample—and shows the precise layout and content you’ll receive after purchase. When you complete your order you’ll instantly unlock and download this same, editable document, formatted and ready to use with no surprises. It’s the real file, complete and production-ready.
Resources
Decades of reputation underpin readers' willingness to pay, reflected in roughly 11.7 million paid subscribers in 2024. High editorial standards attract exclusive sources and a loyal, engaged audience that drives retention and referral. That trust commands premium ad pricing and creates a defensible moat against commoditized news.
Reporters, editors, producers, designers and engineers—supported by roughly 1,700 newsroom staff—drive output quality and audience trust; The New York Times served about 9.3 million paid subscribers in 2024. Specialized desks (investigations, data, visual) create clear differentiation through deep, resource-intensive pieces. Institutional knowledge speeds sourcing and reduces time-to-publish, while high talent density fuels continuous product and editorial innovation.
Proprietary archives dating back to 1851 provide deep context and evergreen value, underpinning reporting and search traffic; the New York Times leverages this historical depth across products. Unique investigations, photography and multimedia—supported by a newsroom of roughly 1,700 journalists—create definable IP for brand differentiation. Active rights management enables syndication and licensing revenue streams, while structured tagging and metadata power personalized feeds for over 10.9 million subscribers.
Technology stack and first-party data
In-house CMS, paywall, analytics and experimentation frameworks drive product growth and retention; first-party behavioral signals from over 10 million paid subscribers in 2024 power personalized recommendations and ad targeting. Scalable cloud infrastructure ensures low-latency delivery, while GDPR/CCPA-compliant data practices sustain a long-term first-party data advantage.
- In-house CMS & paywall
- 10M+ paid subscribers (2024)
- Analytics & experimentation
- Cloud scale + GDPR/CCPA compliance
Large, diversified subscriber base
The New York Times large, diversified subscriber base—about 11 million paying subscribers by mid-2024—provides recurring revenue that stabilizes cash flows and supports predictable digital subscription income. Cross-selling across News, Games, Cooking, and Wirecutter raises ARPU, while network effects drive engagement and community features. Scale expands premium ad inventory and strengthens data-driven audience insights for advertisers.
- Recurring revenue: predictable cash flows
- Cross-sell: higher ARPU across products
- Network effects: stronger community engagement
- Scale: larger ad inventory & richer insights
Decades-long reputation and 11.7 million paid subscribers (2024) underpin predictable subscription revenue and premium ad pricing. Roughly 1,700 newsroom staff and specialized desks produce high-quality, exclusive journalism and multimedia that fuels retention and licensing. Proprietary archives (since 1851), in-house CMS/paywall, and GDPR/CCPA-compliant first-party data power personalization and monetization.
| Metric | 2024 |
|---|---|
| Paid subscribers | 11.7M |
| Newsroom staff | ~1,700 |
| Archives | Since 1851 |
Value Propositions
Accurate, timely and deeply reported coverage reduces information risk for readers and businesses; the New York Times investigative desk, backed by 132 Pulitzer Prizes through 2024, underpins credibility. Investigations and analysis yield actionable insight that informs markets and policy. Over 30 global bureaus deliver local depth, while strict editorial standards ensure reliability in a noisy landscape.
News, Games, Cooking, Wirecutter and podcasts deliver daily utility across information, entertainment and shopping, and by 2024 The New York Times had grown to over 11 million paid subscribers, amplifying bundle reach. Bundling increases perceived value-for-money and stickiness, while cross-content habits reduce churn by broadening daily touchpoints. One account simplifies access and boosts multi-product adoption across platforms.
Apps, web, email, audio and print fit varied routines, supporting The New York Times’ more than 10 million digital subscribers while over 70% of engagement comes from mobile devices. Personalized recommendations surface relevant content efficiently across platforms, alerts and newsletters deliver timely updates to millions, and seamless sync keeps reading progress and saved stories consistent across devices.
Premium advertising and sponsorship solutions
Premium advertising and sponsorship solutions deliver brand-safe environments with The New York Times reaching over 100 million monthly users in 2024, improving campaign outcomes.
Custom content and podcasts provide storytelling depth while contextual and first-party targeting—leveraging over 10 million subscribers in 2024—boosts relevance.
Robust measurement and insights, including attribution and attention metrics, demonstrate ROI and align with advertising representing about 20% of company revenue in 2024.
- Brand-safe: NYT >100M monthly users (2024)
- First-party reach: >10M subscribers (2024)
- Ad share: ~20% of revenue (2024)
- Formats: custom content, podcasts, contextual targeting, measurement
Authoritative reviews and consumer guidance
Wirecutter testing and recommendations de-risk purchases by delivering lab-style reviews and hands-on comparisons; The New York Times reached over 10 million digital-only subscribers in 2024, amplifying distribution and credibility. Transparent methodologies build trust and drive repeat visits; evergreen guides compound organic traffic while affiliate-enabled convenience aligns incentives with measurable commerce revenue.
- de-risking via hands-on testing
- transparent methods = trust
- evergreen guides = sustained SEO traffic
- affiliate links = aligned monetization
Accurate, timely investigative reporting (132 Pulitzers through 2024) reduces information risk and informs markets. Bundled products—News, Games, Cooking, Wirecutter—drive >11M paid subscribers and lower churn. Cross-platform delivery (apps, web, email; >70% mobile engagement) and >100M monthly users create brand-safe reach for advertisers (ads ~20% revenue).
| Metric | 2024 |
|---|---|
| Paid subscribers | >11M |
| Monthly users | >100M |
| Pulitzers | 132 |
| Ad share of revenue | ~20% |
| Mobile engagement | >70% |
Customer Relationships
Tailored onboarding, personalized content suggestions and timely reminders drive habitual reading and helped The New York Times scale engagement as it surpassed roughly 10.9 million total subscribers in 2023, increasing lifetime value per user. Dynamic paywalls and intent-based offers convert casual readers into paid subscribers by matching willingness to pay. Segmented messaging—behavioral and demographic—improved retention rates. Continuous feedback loops from product analytics inform rapid A/B tuning and content curation.
Intuitive self-service portals let the 9.8 million digital subscribers in 2024 manage billing, upgrades and cancellation flows without agent intervention. Transparent controls cut friction and likely reduce support calls. Pausing options give flexible retention during price sensitivity. Clear subscription status reduces fear-driven churn.
Responsive multichannel support (email, live chat, phone, social) addresses issues quickly for the New York Times, serving a readership of over 10 million paid subscribers as of 2024. Rigorous comment moderation and community policies maintain civility and safety across platforms. Reader feedback drives corrections and product features through dedicated feedback flows and newsroom transparency. Visible accountability—corrections and editor notes—reinforces trust.
Newsletters and alert programs
Curated newsletters deepen relationships by delivering topic-focused content that drives habitual engagement and higher open/click-through rates; in 2024 The New York Times reported about 9.6 million paid subscribers, a base that amplifies newsletter reach. Breaking alerts keep users informed in real time, increasing DAU and session frequency. Consistent touchpoints translate into measurable retention and subscription upsell opportunities.
- Curated emails: topical relevance → higher CTR
- Breaking alerts: real-time DAU lift
- Habitual cadence: boosts open rates
- Consistency: drives subscriber growth (9.6M in 2024)
Promotions, trials, and bundles
- Intro pricing: boosts trial-to-paid conversion
- Time-limited: increases sign-up velocity
- Bundles: higher ARPU, cross-sell
- Win-back: recovers churned users
The New York Times drives retention through personalized onboarding, dynamic paywalls and segmented messaging, contributing to 10.9 million total subscribers in 2023 and improved LTV. Self-service portals and pause options reduced friction for 9.8 million digital subscribers in 2024. Multichannel support, moderated communities and curated newsletters (9.6M paid subscribers in 2024) deepen engagement and upsell.
| Metric | Year | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Total subscribers | 2023 | 10.9M |
| Digital subscribers | 2024 | 9.8M |
| Paid subscribers | 2024 | 9.6M |
Channels
Owned website is the primary hub for content consumption, conversions, and ad delivery, centralizing subscription and display inventory. Full control of UX, paywall, and experimentation supports subscription growth—10.9 million digital subscribers (Q2 2024). SEO and direct traffic scale efficiently, reaching roughly 140 million monthly uniques in 2024. Robust analytics deliver rich behavioral insight for personalization and retention.
Native mobile and tablet apps deliver faster rendering and richer multimedia, boosting engagement for The New York Times, which had over 10 million paid subscribers by 2024. Push notifications drive timely reactivation and higher retention, while offline reading and saved stories increase session frequency and subscription value. App store visibility aids discovery and acquisition, supporting digital subscription growth and recurring revenue.
NYT email newsletters are a direct, high-intent channel with average open rates around 35% in 2024, driving engaged readership. Topic-specific editions like DealBook and Morning Briefing enable personalization at scale using first-party data tied to NYT's ~8.6 million subscriptions (2024). Sponsored slots command premium CPMs and monetize effectively, boosting digital ad revenue with precise, owned-data targeting.
Audio and podcast platforms
The Daily and NYT podcasts extend storytelling beyond text, with The Daily averaging about 2 million downloads per episode in 2024; host‑read ads and sponsorships deliver higher rates, driving premium audio ad revenue. Regular serialized episodes build routine listening and loyalty, while distribution partnerships (Apple, Spotify, smart speakers) scale reach and subscription funnels.
- reach: The Daily ~2M downloads/episode (2024)
- monetization: host‑read ads command premium rates
- engagement: routine listening builds loyalty
- scale: platform partnerships expand distribution
Print distribution
Print distribution remains a legacy channel serving loyal readers and institutions, contributing to The New York Times's paid reach amid 9.6 million total subscribers in 2024; print preserves engagement with older, high-LTV cohorts.
Physical presence reinforces brand stature in key markets, weekend editions drive habitual consumption and command premium ad inventory, and bundled print-plus-digital packages extend lifetime value and revenue diversification.
- 2024 total subscribers: 9.6 million
- Approx. print paid circulation: ~300,000 weekday / ~700,000 weekend
- Weekend print CPMs typically 2–3x digital rates, boosting ad revenue
Owned website drives subscriptions and ads with 10.9 million digital subscribers (Q2 2024) and ~140M monthly uniques. Mobile apps and push increase engagement and retention; app discovery supports recurring revenue. Email newsletters average ~35% opens, fueling high-intent conversions; The Daily podcast ~2M downloads/episode (2024). Print serves older, high-LTV readers with ~300k weekday / ~700k weekend circulation.
| Channel | Key metrics (2024) |
|---|---|
| Website | 10.9M digital subs; ~140M monthly uniques |
| Apps | Drives retention, discovery via app stores |
| ~35% open rate; high conversion | |
| Podcasts | The Daily ~2M downloads/ep |
| ~300k weekday / ~700k weekend circ. |
Customer Segments
Global news readers seek reliable coverage of national and world events, valuing depth, analysis and rapid breaking updates; The New York Times reported roughly 10.9 million total subscriptions by 2024, reflecting paid demand for trustworthy sources. About 22% of people globally pay for online news (Reuters Institute 2024), and ~69% consume news primarily via smartphones, underscoring cross-device habits.
Professionals, policymakers, and executives rely on the New York Times for concise, high-signal reporting that fits tight schedules. They use NYT insights to inform strategic decisions and policy, often subscribing to premium access and paid newsletters—NYT had over 10 million paid subscribers by 2024 and subscription revenue exceeding $2 billion in 2023. This cohort commands high CLV and attracts premium advertisers paying above-average CPMs.
Households and hobbyists seek entertainment, learning, and lifestyle utility from NYT games and Cooking, with daily crosswords and recipes forming habitual rituals that drive frequent returns. Family-friendly engagement in games and shared meal planning boosts retention across age groups. Bundling games, Cooking, and news increases ARPU; NYT reported about 11 million paid subscribers in 2024, underscoring scale for cross-sell.
Students and educators
Students and educators access the New York Times through discounted individual and institutional pricing; classroom integrations (syllabi, primary-source packs) support curricula and instructor dashboards. Early habit formation among students boosts lifetime value as alumni convert to paid readers. In 2024 the Times continued institutional and campus partnership programs to expand reach.
- Academic discounts
- Classroom integrations
- Early habit → LTV
- Campus partnerships
Advertisers and media buyers
Advertisers and media buyers target The New York Times for access to its roughly 10 million paid subscribers in 2024, a predominantly affluent, highly engaged audience; they prioritize brand-safe, high-attention environments and pay premiums for custom content and robust measurement; campaigns regularly span text, audio and video across newsletters, podcasts and streaming formats.
- Affluent audience: ~10M paid subscribers (2024)
- Priority: brand safety and high attention
- Value: custom content + measurement
- Formats: text, audio, video (multi-format campaigns)
Global readers (news seekers, 10.9M paid subs in 2024) value depth and rapid updates; professionals and policymakers drive premium subscriptions and high CLV; households use Games/Cooking habitually while students and campuses expand lifetime value; advertisers pay premiums for a brand-safe, affluent audience.
| Segment | Metric | 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| Paid subscribers | Scale | 10.9M |
| Subscription revenue | FY | $2B (2023) |
| Mobile news | Share | 69% |
| Paying for news | Global | 22% |
Cost Structure
Salaries, benefits, travel, and investigative resources dominate newsroom costs at The New York Times, reflecting heavy investment in talent and reporting capacity; by 2024 the company supported roughly 10.9 million subscribers, underpinning that spend. Multimedia production for video, audio, and graphics adds complexity and capital outlay as the Times expands visual storytelling. Contributor and licensing fees supplement coverage, while sustained editorial investment remains the primary differentiator.
Cloud hosting, CDN, CMS and data platforms create steady operational spend to serve over 9 million paid NYT subscribers in 2024; app development and QA drive continuous delivery cycles; security, privacy, and compliance constitute fixed overheads for regulated publishing; analytics and experimentation tooling enable A/B testing and personalization at scale.
Performance marketing and brand campaigns drive subscriber and ad growth, supporting the New York Times' over 10 million subscribers in 2024. Sales teams, ad ops, and an in-house creative studio convert audience reach into ad and affiliate revenue. Promotions and trial offers produce identifiable short-term CAC spikes during campaign periods. Analytics and audience research steer monthly spend allocation and channel ROI optimization.
Printing and distribution
Printing and distribution costs center on paper, ink, press time and logistics for print runs; third-party delivery contracts manage regional coverage while returns and waste materially worsen unit economics, pressuring margins and making strict cost control essential to keep print viable.
- Paper and ink procurement
- Press time and maintenance
- Third-party delivery contracts
- Returns, waste and unit-cost impact
- Cost control extends print viability
General and administrative
General and administrative costs cover corporate functions—finance, legal, HR and facilities—forming a steady fixed base that includes insurance and external professional services; these were reported in The New York Times Company 2024 filings as core SG&A categories supporting operations.
IP and litigation management protect content and trademarks, while governance expenses ensure compliance with public-company requirements on the NYSE and SEC reporting in 2024.
- Corporate functions: finance, legal, HR, facilities
- Fixed base: insurance, professional services
- Asset protection: IP, litigation management
- Compliance: public-company governance, SEC/NYSE reporting (2024)
Salaries, newsroom resources, tech/platforms, marketing and print/distribution form The New York Times' primary cost drivers; editorial investment and digital platforms scale to support 10.9 million subscribers (2024). G&A, compliance and IP/lit are steady fixed costs constraining margin management.
| Cost area | 2024 datapoint |
|---|---|
| Subscribers | 10.9M |
Revenue Streams
Digital subscriptions generate recurring revenue across News, Games, Cooking and bundled offers, contributing to over 10.9 million paid subscribers and roughly $1.9 billion in digital subscription revenue in 2024; bundles boost ARPU. Tiered pricing, introductory trials and promotional funnels drive conversion and upsell. Personalization, notifications and habit-forming features raise retention and LTV. Global distribution expands the addressable market and scales unit economics.
Print subscriptions and single-copy sales still generate meaningful revenue for the New York Times through home delivery and newsstand sales, with print-focused weekend packages commanding significant premiums. Bundling print with digital access increases customer stickiness and lifetime value. Institutional print subscriptions and bulk sales to libraries and universities add revenue stability. The Times reported over 10 million paid subscribers in 2024, underscoring print-to-digital synergies.
Advertising and sponsorships span display, native, video, audio and newsletter placements across web, apps and podcasts; in 2024 ads represented about 15% of The New York Times’ revenue, with direct and programmatic channels diversifying demand and reducing volatility. Branded-content studios like T Brand Studio produce higher-margin campaigns, while improved targeting and third-party measurement lift yield and CPMs across formats.
Licensing, syndication, and content rights
Licensing, syndication, and content-rights fees provide The New York Times with recurring income from republishing articles, photos, and data, while international editions and paid reprints extend monetization; podcast licensing and adaptations (including scripted series) increase IP value. Archive access and enterprise licensing to universities, libraries, and corporations monetize historic content; NYT reported about 10.9 million paid subscribers in mid-2024, supporting scale for these deals.
Affiliate and commerce (Wirecutter and beyond)
Affiliate and commerce revenue comes from commission on recommended product purchases; Wirecutter (acquired by NYT for 30 million USD in 2016) underpins this channel. Revenues spike seasonally around Black Friday/Cyber Monday and back-to-school cycles. Trust-driven, editorial reviews drive higher conversion rates, while partnerships broaden merchant coverage and SKU reach.
- commission: merchant-paid referral fees
- seasonality: peaks at major retail events
- trust: editorial reviews lift conversion
- partnerships: expand merchant network
Digital subscriptions drive scale: ~10.9M paid subscribers (mid-2024) and ~$1.9B digital subscription revenue in 2024; tiered bundles and personalization lift ARPU and retention.
Print, single-copy and bundled home delivery remain meaningful revenue and stickiness drivers; institutional print and reprints add stability.
Advertising (~15% of 2024 revenue), licensing, Wirecutter commerce (acquired for 30M USD in 2016) and IP deals diversify income.
| Metric | 2024 |
|---|---|
| Paid subscribers | 10.9M |
| Digital subscription rev | $1.9B |
| Ad share | ~15% |