Brilliant Earth Boston Consulting Group Matrix
Fully Editable
Tailor To Your Needs In Excel Or Sheets
Professional Design
Trusted, Industry-Standard Templates
Pre-Built
For Quick And Efficient Use
No Expertise Is Needed
Easy To Follow
Brilliant Earth Bundle
Actionable Strategy Starts Here
Brilliant Earth’s BCG Matrix preview shows where key products sit now—quick wins, cash generators, and underperformers—but the full picture is where you get real clarity. Purchase the full BCG Matrix for quadrant-by-quadrant placements, data-backed recommendations, and a ready-to-use Word report plus Excel summary so you can act fast. Skip the guesswork—buy the complete analysis and start reallocating capital with confidence.
Stars
Ethical engagement rings leadership
Brilliant Earth rides the engagement-ring wave with ethics front and center, leveraging its 2021 public listing and focus on responsible and lab-grown diamonds to drive trust. High-intent traffic and strong social proof sustain conversion, aligning with the US average engagement-ring spend near 6,000 USD (The Knot). In a growth market with rising demand for ethical options, this is a high-share, high-growth lead to invest in via design refreshes and stronger placement.
Lab-grown & Beyond Conflict Free diamonds
Lab-grown demand is sprinting: industry estimates put lab-grown diamonds at over 10% of US diamond value in 2023 and continuing double-digit growth; Brilliant Earth’s transparency positioning accelerates share gains from legacy players. The segment requires working capital for inventory and marketing, but unit economics and repeat rates show payback within typical jewelry customer LTV horizons. Maintain investment while category expansion persists.
Online-first customization experience
Configurable rings with real-time 3D renders and a tight UX are table stakes for digital jewelry and Brilliant Earth is ahead, driving engagement and average order values roughly 30% above category norms; online jewelry conversion sits near 2.5% in 2024 while their bespoke flows push higher. High engagement, high basket values, and low-friction checkout fuel growth; competitors chase but the feature moat widens. Keep shipping iterative improvements and richer content.
Supply-chain transparency & traceability
Supply-chain transparency and traceability drive purchases for Brilliant Earth by turning provenance into a tangible trust asset; as EU CSRD expanded compliance to about 50,000 companies starting in 2024, regulatory and consumer scrutiny compound this advantage. Investing in tooling and independent audits anchors price and boosts conversion through documented ethical claims. PR value multiplies with verified chains of custody.
- Provenance = purchase driver
- CSRD impact: ~50,000 firms (2024)
- Fund tooling + audits
- Defends premium pricing
Omnichannel showrooms in key cities
Omnichannel showrooms in key metros close the want-to-see-it gap and supercharge online leads, with omnichannel shoppers showing ~1.7x higher lifetime value (Deloitte 2024); same-store growth and halo effects are strongest in major cities, boosting conversion and average order value. Unit economics improve as brand awareness climbs; rollouts should target prime locations with tight formats to preserve ROI.
- Tag: conversion uplift ~1.7x (Deloitte 2024)
- Tag: focus: prime metros, compact footprint
- Tag: KPI: online leads, AOV, same-store growth
Ethical lab-grown diamonds: high-share growth, +30% AOV, omnichannel LTV 1.7x
Brilliant Earth is a Star: high-share in a high-growth ethical/ lab-grown segment (>10% US diamond value in 2023) with AOV ~30% above category and online conversion ~2.5% (2024). Omnichannel shoppers show ~1.7x LTV (Deloitte 2024); CSRD affects ~50,000 firms (2024), reinforcing traceability premium.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| US avg engagement spend | $6,000 (The Knot) |
| Lab-grown share | >10% (2023) |
| Online conversion | ~2.5% (2024) |
| AOV vs category | +30% |
| Omnichannel LTV | ~1.7x (Deloitte 2024) |
What is included in the product
Detailed Word Document
BCG Matrix review of Brilliant Earth: identifies Stars, Cash Cows, Question Marks and Dogs and gives invest, hold or divest recommendations.
Customizable Excel Spreadsheet
One-page BCG matrix highlighting Brilliant Earth's units to cut analysis time and ease C-level decisions.
Cash Cows
Wedding bands (repeat and bundles)
Wedding bands sit firmly in Brilliant Earth’s cash cow quadrant: mature demand, steady inventory turns and predictable margins driven by cross-sell from engagement ring purchases, which account for the majority of band attach rates; low promotional intensity and high customer attachment keep CAC efficient. Milk via curated assortments, tiered bundling and streamlined fulfillment to maximize lifetime value and margin stability.
Classic solitaire settings
Classic solitaire settings are timeless SKUs that rarely go out of style, representing roughly one-third of engagement-ring purchases in US surveys (2024). With high share and low trend risk, demand is stable and forecasting is straightforward. Limited design refreshes and strong gross margins enable steady cash generation. Optimize fulfillment and inventory to let them print cash.
Organic SEO and evergreen content
Years of guides and comparison content compound traffic—organic search drives about 53% of website traffic (BrightEdge 2023), letting Brilliant Earth capture sustainable visitors. Stable rankings reduce paid spend dependency; paid search often contributes ~15% of traffic (industry averages 2023). Conversion paths are well-worn and measurable; ecommerce average conversion ≈2.5% (Adobe 2023). Maintain, update lightly, enjoy the flow.
Custom design fees and upsells
Custom design fees and upsells at Brilliant Earth—tweaks, metal choices, and stone upgrades—drive steady, high-contribution revenue with low incremental cost per order. 2024 performance showed these services remain consistent profit drivers rather than scalable growth engines. Standardizing workflows and modular SKU/production steps can raise margin capture on each sale.
- customers pay for tweaks, metals, stone upgrades
- low incremental cost, tidy contribution margins
- 2024: consistent, not hyper-growth
- standardize workflows to squeeze more margin
Care plans, resizing, cleaning services
Care plans, resizing and cleaning services are classic cash cows: low CAC, predictable recurring revenue and high facility utilization that require little marketing push. These after-sale services stabilize margins and lifetime value while driving loyalty and referrals through routine customer contact. Keep packages simple, transparent pricing and clean margin accounting to preserve profitability.
Rings, solitaires & after-sales drive margins; organic search 53%, conv. ~2.5%
Wedding bands, classic solitaires and after-sale services form Brilliant Earth cash cows: stable demand, strong margins, high attach and efficient CAC; organic search (53% BrightEdge 2023) and steady conversion (~2.5% Adobe 2023) underpin low paid spend; 2024 custom-design fees remained consistent profit contributors. Standardize fulfillment and service workflows to protect margins.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Solitaire share (2024) | ~33% |
| Organic traffic (2023) | 53% |
| Site conversion (2023) | ~2.5% |
Delivered as Shown
Brilliant Earth BCG Matrix
The file you're previewing on this page is the exact BCG Matrix report you'll receive after purchase. No watermarks, no demo text—just the fully formatted, ready-to-use document built for strategic clarity. Once bought, the same file is delivered to your inbox for immediate download and editing. Designed by strategy pros, it’s presentation-ready for meetings, decks, or planning.
Dogs
Slow-turn fashion jewelry SKUs
Trend-chasing fashion-jewelry SKUs tie up cash with inventory days often exceeding 180 days and inventory turnover under 3x, driving markdowns commonly in the 30–50% range in 2024; low search intent and price-sensitive shoppers make conversion costly. These pieces rarely build brand equity and increase carrying costs, so prune hard and exit styles fast to protect gross margins and working capital.
Unverified mined diamonds (limited provenance)
Unverified mined diamonds with limited provenance undercut Brilliant Earth's core ethical differentiation, and customers notice which reduces conversion and repeat purchase behavior. Market positioning shows these SKUs sit in a low-growth, low-share quadrant compared with verified, traceable diamonds. Recommended actions: phase out or strictly ring-fence sales, marketing, and reporting to protect brand integrity.
Print catalogs and legacy collateral
Print catalogs and legacy collateral cost roughly $2–4 per piece to produce and mail and show declining engagement, with prospect response rates commonly in the low single digits, making attribution weak and incremental ROI rarely clearing corporate thresholds in 2024. Digital-first buyers ignore printed touchpoints; reallocating that budget to performance channels (higher measurable ROAS) and improving showroom experience yields better returns. Wind down print runs and redeploy spend to digital acquisition and in-store conversion.
Long-tail international shipping with high returns
Far-flung markets cause logistics pain and refund risk: 2024 cross-border jewelry return rates approach 20–25%, while transit adds 10–30 days and shipping costs often raise unit costs by 15–25%, squeezing thin margins on small volumes and high service loads; cash is trapped in transit and inventory, so tighten zones or partner locally to reduce days-in-transit and return exposure.
- High return risk: 20–25% (2024)
- Long transit: +10–30 days
- Unit cost lift: +15–25%
Niche colored gemstone one-offs
Dogs: niche colored gemstone one-offs suffer fragmented demand, hard-to-source consistency and rare repeats; visually strong on Instagram but poor contributors to P&L, so they sit in low-share, low-predictability territory in Brilliant Earth’s 2024 BCG mapping. Limit SKUs or treat as occasional drops only.
- Low share, low predictability
- Fragmented demand; sourcing variability
- High marketing lift, low margin impact
- Restrict SKUs; occasional curated drops
Gemstone one-offs are low-share Dogs — inv >180 days, turnover <3x, markdowns 30–50%
Colored-gemstone one-offs are low-share, low-growth Dogs for Brilliant Earth in 2024: inventory days >180, turnover <3x, markdowns 30–50% and high marketing CPL with poor repeat purchase. They erode gross margin and brand clarity; restrict SKUs and offer as occasional curated drops only.
| Metric | 2024 |
|---|---|
| Inventory days | >180 |
| Turnover | <3x |
| Markdowns | 30–50% |
Question Marks
EU and APAC expansion
EU and APAC represent large addressable markets—APAC drives roughly half of global jewelry demand while Europe comprises about one-fifth—yet strong local incumbents and fragmented regulation limit quick share gains.
Brilliant Earth sees rising brand awareness but not proportional share growth; customer acquisition costs and operational complexity in cross‑border compliance and supply chain create material margins pressure.
Prioritize doubling down in select APAC hubs with proven unit economics and regulatory clarity; pause broad EU rollouts until CACs normalize and localized partnerships reduce operational risk.
Lab-grown colored diamonds
Lab-grown colored diamonds are hot on socials—engagements up ~25% in 2024—but mainstream pull remains unclear as lab-grown diamonds held roughly 10% of the US diamond market by value in 2024. Margins can be strong if Brilliant Earth’s premium positioning lands; the line could become a hero or stall as a fad. Test-and-scale with tight cohorts (start 1–3% of customers), track conversion and AOV closely.
Loyalty and membership programs
Engagement ring purchases are rare—average US spend about $6,200 per The Knot 2022—yet related life events (anniversaries, gifts) create recurring touchpoints a membership could capture. A smart loyalty/membership program can bridge low purchase frequency to repeat spend across anniversaries and gifting occasions, turning one-time buyers into repeat customers. Economics remain unproven at scale; pilot targeted benefits and measure incremental LTV lift before roll‑out.
Consumer-facing provenance tech (QR/blockchain)
Consumer-facing provenance tech (QR/blockchain) is a strong narrative for Brilliant Earth but willingness to pay is unclear; industry pilots (Everledger reported tracking north of 3 million assets by 2024) show credibility upside. If provenance raises trust and ARPU it becomes a moat; if it adds friction it hurts conversion. Prototype on high-ticket SKUs, measure uplift in conversion and AOV.
- Test: pilot 3–5 premium SKUs
- Metrics: conversion, AOV, repeat rate
- Risk: UX friction vs trust gain
Recycled gold men’s jewelry line
Brilliant Earth’s recycled-gold men’s line sits as a Question Mark: the men’s jewelry category has been one of the fastest-growing segments in fine jewelry (multi-year CAGR ~5–7% through 2024), yet men’s assortment remains a small share of total sales; ethical sourcing is a clear brand fit but male taste is fragmented, requiring focused assortment choices.
Core strategy: launch core silhouettes (bands, chains, signet styles), iterate fast to drive post-engagement repeat purchases and LTV uplift while monitoring conversion and AOV closely.
- tag:growth ~5–7% CAGR through 2024
- tag:share small — men’s comprises a minority of sales
- tag:ethical fit — recycled gold differentiator
- tag:product — start with core silhouettes, rapid iteration
- tag:opportunity — unlock repeat purchases post-engagement
APAC ~50% demand; EU ~20%; lab-grown ~10% US; pilot men's 5-7% CAGR
APAC (~50% of global jewelry demand in 2024) and EU (~20% in 2024) are large but locally competitive, limiting fast share gains.
Lab-grown diamonds ~10% of US diamond value in 2024; social buzz up ~25% but mainstream conversion unclear—test cohorts tightly.
Men’s recycled-gold line targets a 5–7% CAGR segment (through 2024); pilot core silhouettes, track conversion, AOV, repeat rate.
| Metric | 2024 |
|---|---|
| APAC share | ~50% |
| EU share | ~20% |
| Lab-grown US value | ~10% |
| Men’s CAGR | 5–7% |